Wednesday, February 13, 2008

TA, Alternative Assessment

Yesterday in class we talked about alternative assessment and it really struck my interest. I enjoyed going over all the benefits and concerns associated with moving away from standardized testing and going toward testing with essay questions, short answer, portfolios, etc....

At first alternative assessment seems like a really good idea to me. It allows for creativity and thinking. It allows for personal effort on the student's part along with a more personalized grading system. This type of testing would be great for smaller scale assessment such as a particular class or school.

I was turned off to the idea though when we started examining some of the disadvantages. We talked about how the grading process is so much more subjective with Alternative Assessment. It would be so easy for a teacher to grade some students harder than others based on the student's behavior in class, the teacher's attitude toward the student, and any personal predjudices or predispositions a teacher has toward his/her students. For example, a teacher could develop a predjudice against a disruptive student that could influence how hard that teacher graded said student on the assessments.

An answer to this problem would be to have a third party actually grade the tests. This would allow for an objective approach to grading. While increasing cost and perhaps complicating the process to a small degree, a third party grading system would ensure that each assessment be graded in a totally objective manner, only taking into account the work of the student.

This could be a great topic for my paper on Education. Maybe I could look up studies on the advantages and disadvantages of alternative assessment in certain areas. I could argue that alternative assessment can be too subjective if not checked by objectivity.


Revision

Yesterday in class we talked about alternative assessment and it really struck my interest. I enjoyed discussing the benefits and concerns associated with moving away from standardized testing to testing with essay questions, short answer, portfolios, etc....

At first alternative assessment seems like a positive change. It allows for creative thinking. It demands personal effort on the student's part along with a personalized grading. This type of testing would benefit smaller scale assessment such as a particular class or school.

I was turned off to the idea though when we started examining some of the disadvantages. We talked about how the grading process is dangerously subjective with Alternative Assessment. It would be so easy for a teacher to grade some students harder than others based on the student's behavior in class, the teacher's attitude toward the student, and any personal predjudices or predispositions a teacher has toward his/her students. For example, a teacher could develop a predjudice against a disruptive student that could influence how hard that teacher graded said student on the assessments.

An answer to this problem would be to have a third party actually grade the tests. This would allow for an objective approach to grading. While increasing cost and perhaps complicating the process to a small degree, a third party grading system would ensure that each assessment be graded in a totally objective manner, only taking into account the work of the student.

This could be a great topic for my paper on Education. Maybe I could look up studies on the advantages and disadvantages of alternative assessment in certain areas. I could argue that alternative assessment can be too subjective if not checked by objectivity.

1 comment:

Steph said...

Great post. I thought this was a very interesting topic as well, and you touched on some very key points. Good luck on your paper!